Comanchero MC members drove from Auckland to Mount Maunganui for a robbery – then targeted the wrong house.
The group was sent to take “whatever drugs and money they could find” from a suspected drug dealer early on July 20, 2018, a Court of Appeal decision said.
That plan “misfired” as the property they forced their way into was home to an innocent couple who had no drugs and just $40 cash.
The two carloads of Comanchero MC members used a sledgehammer to force their way into the house -near where their target lived – about 4.20am.
Guns were pointed at the couple, and they were threatened with death, beatings, and their dog being shot, the judgment said.
But one of the offenders, William Matiu Court-Clausen, has just had a year and a half taken off his jail term on appeal.
He will now spend seven years and six months in prison, as the Court of Appeal found the robbery wasn’t violent enough to warrant his initial sentence.
Still, the judgment acknowledged “serious repeated threats made with loaded firearms”, the planning, and the criminal gang link.
- A Comanchero bikie is among seven people arrested as police crackdown on firearms.
- Ex-Nomads outlaw gang president says his cousin Sam Ibrahim will ‘live like a king’ when he’s deported to Lebanon – and claims the notorious bikie boss is filthy rich
- 40-year-old’s double life as a co-founder of a notorious chapter of the biker gang East Coast Syndicate.
- Millard County prosecutors unveiled an avalanche of incriminating evidence in a high-profile theft case involving Grim Reapers MC member
- The pickup truck driver charged with causing the deaths of seven motorcyclists told authorities he had drug problem. NTSB Releases Details
Court-Clausen was arrested later on the morning of the robbery, when he tried to hitch-hike out of Tauranga – with a police officer.
He and his co-offenders had escaped from the house after police arrived with only tasers and pepper spray.
One offender threw a loaded shotgun out of the car as they were chased, then a second fleeing vehicle was driven on the wrong side of a major Mt Maunganui road.
The group ditched that and escaped across a golf course and Tauranga Airport.
Seventeen months after his arrest, Court-Clausen pleaded guilty.
He was 30 years old when he and he and two co-offenders were sentenced on June 8, 2020.
At sentencing, Judge Thomas Ingram noted vulnerable victims had been held at gunpoint and assaulted in their own home, with “moderate” violence.
It was “easily the most carefully planned and professionally executed aggravated robbery of its type that [he was] aware of in New Zealand”.
The Court of Appeal ruled there wasn’t enough violence involved in the robbery to warrant an 11-year starting point for Court-Clausen’s sentence.
“We do not underestimate in any way the seriousness of the offending of Mr Court-Clausen and his associates,” the judgment said.
“We unreservedly share the Judge’s concern that it involved a significant degree of planning and was executed in a way that must have caused considerable distress to the victims.”
But previous cases with a starting point around 11 years involved “far greater injuries” to victims.
One example, Royal v R, involved three armed intruders dressed as police officers, who bound and gagged six people who lived in the house and subjected one to a “vicious assault”.
A background report on Court-Clausen said he had a lifelong addiction to drugs and impaired mental health.
He left school at 12 and had struggled to come to terms with childhood abuse from whānau members, the report said.
He joined the Comancheros for support after being deported from Australia and separated from connections there – although his wife and children moved to New Zealand.